Problem Type

 

Logical Problem

 

Algorithm

 

Story Problem

 

Rule-Using Problem

 

Decision making

 

Trouble-shooting

 

Diagnosis-Solution

 

Tactical-Strategic Perfomrance

 

Situated Case

 

Designs

 

Dilemmas

 

Outcome

 

efficient solution

 

correct solution

  •  

    correct solution

  •  

    information

     

    Decision about alternatives

     

    fault isolation

     

    fault identification and treatment

     

    Mission performance with situated awareness

     

    problem representation, policy determination, implications, and argumentation

     

    problem articulation, options, design, argumentation

     

    Complex, non-predictive

     

    Problem

     

    logical manipulation

     

    procedural, algorithmic

     

    identify variables, insert & solve, practice

     

    procedural

     

    Advantages, disadvantages & weighting

    of options

     

    search & replace, serial elimination, space splitting

     

    serial elimination, problem schemas, management

     

    Strategic and procedural knowledge; psychomotor performance

     

    Represent problem, alternative actions, reconcile with system, argumentation

     

    original, principle-based

     

    vexing decision, no solution; perspective irreconcilable

     

    Solution

     

    single, clear criteria

     

    single, clear criteria

     

    single, clear criteria

     

    productivity, relevance, correctness

     

    Selection of alternative

     

    correct fault, efficiency

     

    optional, must be defended

     

    Successful mission; accommodating unpredictable events

     

    Multiple options, unclear, on multiple levels

     

    multiple, undefined criteria

     

    articulated preference, preferred decision

     

    Context

     

    abstract task

     

    abstract, formulaic

     

    constrained to pre-defined elements, shallow context

     

    purposeful academic, real world, constrained

     

    Life decisions

     

    closed system real world

     

    real world, technical, mostly closed system

     

    real time; technical; stress loaded

     

    Real world, constrained or open

     

    complex, real world

     

    topical, complex, inter-disciplinary

     

    Example

     

    Tower of Hanoi, Cannabals & Missionaries

    Rubics Cube; geometry proofs

     

    conversions, algebra problems

     

    textbook problems, homework

     

    online searching, calculating materials, expanding recipes

     

    Should I move/ take another job; which school should my daughter attend; deciding on benefits package

     

    troubleshoot mechanical systems

     

    Auto mechanics, medical

     

    Flying a jet fighter; performing surgury; day trading

     

    Business cases; policy issues; litigation

     

    architecture, engineering, instructional design; developing curriculum; managing portfolio

     

    Should abortions be banned?; Kosovo;

     

    Stucturedness

     

    discovered

     

    procedural predictable

     

    procedural predictable

     

    unpredicted outcome

     

    finite outcomes

     

    finite faults & outcomes

     

    finite faults & outcomes

     

    Well-structured task; unpredictable intrusions and outcomes

     

    Ill-structured

     

    ill-structured

     

    finite outcomes, multiple reasoning

     

    Abstractness

     

    abstract, discovery

     

    abstract, procedural

     

    limited simulation

     

    need-based

     

    personally situated

     

    problem

    situated

     

    problem situated

     

    Performance with situated awareness

     

    Multiple situated, different needs

     

    problem situated

     

    issue situated

     

    Complexity

     

    limited but unknown

     

    limited

     

    two stage

     

    multiple rules

     

    user-defined rules

     

    depends on factors

     

    multiple factors on 2 stages

     

    Complex, time constrained

     

    very complex

     

    very complex

     

    unknown & unpredictable

     Back