|
Problem Type |
Logical Problem |
Algorithm |
Story Problem |
Rule-Using Problem |
Decision making |
Trouble-shooting |
Diagnosis-Solution |
Tactical-Strategic Perfomrance |
Situated Case |
Designs |
Dilemmas |
|
Outcome |
efficient solution |
correct solution |
correct solution |
information |
Decision about alternatives |
fault isolation |
fault identification and treatment |
Mission performance with situated awareness |
problem representation, policy determination, implications, and argumentation |
problem articulation, options, design, argumentation |
Complex, non-predictive |
|
Problem |
logical manipulation |
procedural, algorithmic |
identify variables, insert & solve, practice |
procedural |
Advantages, disadvantages & weighting of options |
search & replace, serial elimination, space splitting |
serial elimination, problem schemas, management |
Strategic and procedural knowledge; psychomotor performance |
Represent problem, alternative actions, reconcile with system, argumentation |
original, principle-based |
vexing decision, no solution; perspective irreconcilable |
|
Solution |
single, clear criteria |
single, clear criteria |
single, clear criteria |
productivity, relevance, correctness |
Selection of alternative |
correct fault, efficiency |
optional, must be defended |
Successful mission; accommodating unpredictable events |
Multiple options, unclear, on multiple levels |
multiple, undefined criteria |
articulated preference, preferred decision |
|
Context |
abstract task |
abstract, formulaic |
constrained to pre-defined elements, shallow context |
purposeful academic, real world, constrained |
Life decisions |
closed system real world |
real world, technical, mostly closed system |
real time; technical; stress loaded |
Real world, constrained or open |
complex, real world |
topical, complex, inter-disciplinary |
|
Example |
Tower of Hanoi, Cannabals & Missionaries Rubics Cube; geometry proofs |
conversions, algebra problems |
textbook problems, homework |
online searching, calculating materials, expanding recipes |
Should I move/ take another job; which school should my daughter attend; deciding on benefits package |
troubleshoot mechanical systems |
Auto mechanics, medical |
Flying a jet fighter; performing surgury; day trading |
Business cases; policy issues; litigation |
architecture, engineering, instructional design; developing curriculum; managing portfolio |
Should abortions be banned?; Kosovo; |
|
Stucturedness |
discovered |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Ill-structured |
|
finite outcomes, multiple reasoning |
|
Abstractness |
abstract, discovery |
|
|
|
|
situated |
|
Performance with situated awareness |
Multiple situated, different needs |
|
issue situated |
|
Complexity |
limited but unknown |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
very complex |
|
unknown & unpredictable |