Peer Assessment of Group 13
C A T E G O R Y G6 G7 G8 G9 G10 Average
Topic Selection
(0-20)
19 19 20 20 19 19.6
Newspaper and Article Selection
(0-10)
9 8 9 10 9 9
Quality of Editorial Comments
(0-10)
9 7 10 8 8 8.4
Organic Chemistry Content
(0-10)
8 9 10 9 4 8
Selection and Quality of the Links 
(0-20)
19 16 20 18 18 18.2
Format, Number and Types of Questions
(0-10)
9 7 10 10 8 8.8
Quality of the Questions
(0-10)
9 8 10 9 8 8.8
Overall Impression 
(0-10)
9 6 9 9 8 8.2
TOTAL 91 80 98 93 87 89.8

 
 

Evaluation by Group 6

(A)  Group 6  Ejaz 
(B)  Group 13 Organic Machiene
(C)
1.  Topic Selection: 19 pts.
Interesting topic that can catch the reader's attention and related well
with organic chemistry. 

2.  Newspaper and Article Selection: 9 pts.
The article is from a good newspaper and is published recently.

3.  Quality of the Editorial Comments:  9 pts.
The editorial comments are well organized and further help understand
the article.

4.  Organic Chemistry Content: 8 pts.
Important compounds have been linked and are beneficial in understanding
the chemistry involved in the article.

5.  Selection and Quality of the Links:  19 pts.
The links were very helpful in understanding background information on
the topic.

6.  Format, Number and Types of Questions:  9 pts.
Good questions that covered the material.

7.  Quality of Questions:  9 pts.
There were a wide variety of questions that addressed central issues.

8:  Overall Impression:  9 pts.
Good project and with an interesting topic and pertinence to organic
chemistry.

Total= 91 pts.

 
 

Evaluation by Group 7

(A) Group #7 Morning Addition
(B) Group #13 Organic Machine
(C) Responses:
	1: 19  Interesting to the interest of the nation.  Good relation
to chemistry.
	2: 8 It's acceptable, but short and slightly boring.
	3: 7 Oversimplified and not very fluid.  Overall not extremely
effective, but definitely get the point across.
	4: 9 Good content.
	5: 16 Members of aol is interesting, but not necessarily
credible.  The second and third link have the same source.  Embedded
fairly well.
	6: 7 All 5 questions, but none directly related to the chapter.
They all seemed to be straight from the reading passage.
	7: 8 Very clear and direct, but very easy.
	8: 6  

 
 

Evaluation by Group 8

(A)Group 8: The Underground (Formerly known as Don's Group)

(B)Group 13: Organic Machine

(C)
   1)Topic Selection: 20 points
           The article was good and relevant to organic chemistry.

   2)Newspaper and Article Selection: 9 points
           Although this was a good reliable soure the requirement
           was a newspaper, sorry.

   3)Quality of Editorial Comments: 10 points
           The editorial comments were nicely written and well
           organized.

   4)Organic Chemisty Content: 10 points
           The organic chemistry was well defined and organized.

   5)Selection and Quality of Links: 20 points
           The links were good and relevant to the topic.

   6)Format, Number, and Types of Questions: 10 points
           The questions were well written and covered the
           requirement.

   7)Quality of Questions: 10 points
           The questions were relevant and easily understandable.

   8)Overall Impression: 9 points
           The article was good, but in the editorial comment the
           interaction of the chemicals (reactions) and how this
           happened would have enhanced it.

Total of points allocated: 98 out of 100.

 
 

Evaluation by Group 9

A Group 9
B Group 13
C
    1. Topic Selection: 20/20
    2. Newspaper and article selection: 10/10
    3. Organic chemistry content: 8/10
    4. Organic chemistry content: 9/10 - I would have liket o seen a
structure
    5. Selection and qualtiy of links: 18/20 - Links were a bit dry.  We
have already read one news paper type article, no try to give us the rest
of the                    information in a different fashion.
    6. Format, number, and types of questions:  10/10
    7. Quality of questions: 9/10 - didn't readily link to organic
chemistry. 

    8. Overall impression: 9/10
Total - 93/100 

 
 

Evaluation by Group 10

(A) Group 10 JDK
(B) Group 13 Organic Machine
(C)
1.  Topic Selection 19 pts
The topic is of interest to all the animal activists among us.

2. Newspaper and Article Selection 9 pts
Good source, but the article wasn’t very exciting

3.  Quality of Editorial Comments 8 pts
Well written comments however we were left confused why the problem was
concentrated at animals higher in the food chain.

4.  Organic Chemistry Content 9 pts
The editorial comments tended to focus on the environment and not on
organic chemistry

5.  Selection and Quality of Links 18 pts
Good Links however some of them are repetitive

6.  Format, Number, and Types of Questions 8pts
The type of questions did not vary much.

7. Quality of Questions 8 pts
There were no "real" chemistry questions asking questions about mechanisms
or syntheses.  

8.  Overall Impression 8 pts
Improvement of the questions would improve the entire project.

87