Peer Assessment of Group 9
C A T E G O R Y G4 G5 G6 Average
Topic Selection
(0-20)
20 20 20 20
Newspaper and Article Selection
(0-10)
10 10 9 9.7
Quality of Editorial Comments
(0-10)
10 10 10 10
Organic Chemistry Content
(0-10)
10 10 10 10
Selection and Quality of the Links
(0-20)
20 19 20 19.7
Format, Number and Types of Questions
(0-10)
10 10 10 10
Quality of the Questions
(0-10)
10 10 10 10
Overall Impression 
(0-10)
10 10 10 10
TOTAL 100 99 99 99.3

 
 

Evaluation by Group 4

(A) Evaluating Group: #4 Die Absoluten Nullpunkte
(B) Evaluated Group:  #9 HMO Stars
(C) Responses to Evaluation Categories
(1) Topic Selection:  20/20
It was a good topic, relevant, one that most people would look at for fun.
(2) Newspaper and Article Selection:  10/10
It was a novel, credible source and the article was a good length.
(3) Quality of the Editorial Comments:  10/10
Excellent!
(4) Organic Chemistry Content:  10/10
It addressed many topics that we have covered indepth.
(5) Selection and Quality of the Links:  20/20
All of the links gave interestion information that aided in the 
understanding and the answering of the questions.
(6) Format, Number and Types of Questions:  10/10
Met the requirements.
(7) Quality of the Questions:  10/10
All of the questions were pertinent and challenging.
(8) Overall Impression:  10/10
Publish it as is!!!  Excellence is a habit!

 
 

Evaluation by Group 5

(A) Group 5: Carbon Conquerors

(B) Group 9: The HMO Stars

(C)

(1) Topic Selection: 20 points (0-20)
Important to a wide range of people and relation to organic chemistry.

(2)  Newspaper and Article Selection: 10 points (0-10)
High quality choice.

(3) Quality of the Editorial Comments: 10 points (0-10)
Addresses the relationship to organic chemistry well.

(4) Organic Chemistry Content: 10 points (0-10)
It is quite obvious!

(5) Selection and Quality of the Links: 19 points (0-20)
Very good, but one required us to download something that took a little
while.

(6) Format, Number, and Types of questions: 10 points (0-10)
Way to have more than 4!!!!!

(7) Quality of the Questions: 10 points (0-10)
WOW!!!!! if we could give extra credit.....

(8) Overall Impression: 10 points (0-10)
You guys did a very good job!

Total Points: 99

I doubt you'll have questions about our grading, but if you do, deal
with the fact that you lost a point. 
Good job. :)

 
 

Evaluation by Group 6

(A) Group 6: Ethanol Absorbers 
(B) Group 9: The HMO Stars
(C) Responses to Evaluation Categories:
(1) Topic Selection:  20/20
Topic was a great choice.  Very interesting.
(2) Newspaper and Article Selection: 9/10
Great choice of article.  Although we don't want to take away from the
quality of the article, it wasn't very recent. (3/25/99)  
(3) Quality of the Editorial Coments:  10/10
The comments were well organized and gave a greater understanding of the
article.
(4) Organic Chemistry Content:  10/10
The comments were well related to organic chemistry.
(5) Selection and Quality of the Links:  20/20
The links were all good sites that enhanced the understanding of the
article. 
(6) Format, Number and Types of Questions:  10/10
Questions were varied and had good format.
(7) Quality of the Questions:  10/10
The quality of the questions was great.  The questions were well thought
out.
(8) Overall Impression:  10/10
Great article.  
Total Points 99/100